A fellow at a book panel in Newburyport, Mass. last week asked an interesting question of his panel of mystery writers. Why write mysteries? Why not write something else?
Luckily I was second in line, behind Linda Barnes , for this one (left to right in photo, Linda Barnes, yours truly, Hallie Ephron, and moderator and author Dyke Hendrickson), giving me a few minutes to collect my thoughts. Why write crime novels? Why not westerns? Poetry? “Literary” novels?
Why, indeed.
I answered the question but now, with time to consider it more, I’ll answer it a little better.
I’ve been reading about a case in New Hampshire, where a woman named Krista Dittmeyer, just 20 years old, was found dead in a pond at a ski area. Her car was parked nearby, flashers on. Her 18-month old daughter was still strapped in her car seat , unharmed.
Krista is from Portland, Maine, a waitress by occupation. In her photo, which runs with all the stories, she’s pretty and cheerful, looks like somebody who was full of fun. Her relatives say she was a good mom, loved her little girl. Her boyfriend, the child’s father, is in jail for drug trafficking—twelve grams of coke and a couple grand. Relatively minor f but enough to take him out of circulation.
As I write this it’s been almost a week and no cause of death has been released. David Hench, police reporter for the Portland Press Herald, has done some good stories on the case, explaining what the lack of hard information could mean. Requests for toxicology reports could mean no obvious cause was found. Or investigators know what happened and are looking for evidence to bolster their case. In the meantime, the public waits and wonders.
Did she leave her home voluntarily? What was she doing in Conway, N.H.? If she was abducted and killed, did the killers deliberately spare the child? If it wasn’t foul play, why would she leave her child unattended in a deserted,dark place? What the hell happened?
Most likely police will figure it out, with the autopsy, countless interviews, unraveling the case in that patient, dogged way good cops do. They don’t give up easily. In a cases like this, assuming it’s a homicide, they don’t give up at all.
But there’s a chance, I suppose, that they haven’t and won’t figure this one out. The Maine State Police have a whole web page devoted to unsolved murders. They go back years, the cases that are cold but not forgotten. And while I don’t know how the Krista Dittmeyer case will play out, I do know one thing: it this were a crime novel, and I were writing it, the killer or killers would be brought to justice.
I’ve been told that mystery novelists have a fascination with crime. Maybe, but mostly they have a need to see justice done. It hurts them to see real life crime. Their response—and mine—is to create a world where bad guys don’t get away with it, where good vanquishes evil, where you know that when the books ends, this crime will not stand.
I can picture a book based on a case like this one: the child alone in the car is an opening scene that gives me chills. But I’m going to settle for watching the newspapers for each report, and waiting for the truth to come out. I hope that, just like in a crime novel, it does. And if justice is needed, it is served out in spades.












In PORT CITY SHAKEDOWN, the first Brandon Blake novel, Brandon gets a full dose of bad guys. A brawl in a funeral home introduces him to Joel Fuller, a sociopathic hustler. Fuller is fresh out of jail and determined to take Brandon out—after Fuller and his sidekick Kelvin shake him down.
Rocky isn’t a tough guy. He’s a skinny little kid with crooked glasses, and he shouldn’t be homeless in Portland, Maine. When McMorrow and Roxanne pluck him from under the stomping feet of a gang of street kids, Rocky latches onto McMorrow–and drags him into a world of murder, both old and new. Why is McMorrow protecting Rocky? The cops want to know. Why is Rocky on the run? McMorrow wants to know. Why does death follow in Rocky’s wake? Jack and Roxanne need to find out before they’re added to the list.