ABOUT THE BOOKSTHE JACK MCMORROW MYSTERIESBRANDON BLAKE: A CRIME NOVEL

June 23rd, 2010

One to retweet

When DEADLINE was published there were  newspaper reviews. Now there are online reviews. To which do you give more weight?

5 Responses to “One to retweet”

  1. patrick foster says:

    Have to say online; the only paper I read – irregularly- doesn’t review books. (Or doesn’t on the days I have my hands on one.)

  2. Gerry says:

    And therein lies the problem, Patrick. Most newspapers don’t review books anymore (one of the first things to go in the economic downturn). So how to get the word out? Which online review sites do you readers see?

  3. amkuhl says:

    Gerry,
    I always read the NYT movie reviews, and the book reviews as well. I also google reviews of books, and read anything that seems to be a reputable paper or critic. But I never read them until after I’ve finished the book/movie, due to the spoilers. That probably seems backwards to people, reading the reviews after reading the book or seeing the movie, but I like to see if my opinions jive with the “experts’”.

    What about you?
    Andrea

  4. Gerry says:

    I see the AP national reviews, and NYT reviews. If something sounds interesting, I’ll make a mental note. I tend to read reviews of nonfiction and to stay away from crime/mystery reviews. I don’t want other writers’ plots in my head too much, which is why I tend to read writers who are long dead. I stay away from reviews of my own books. If there is a good one in a prominent place (like the Publishers Weekly for DAMAGED GOODS, I’ll hear about it. I’ve been warned by other writers that you can actually start writing in reaction to reviews, what they liked, what they didn’t, and it can mess you up. You don’t want that added layer of self-consciousness.

  5. amkuhl says:

    That’s very interesting, and it sounds like what actors go through…changing in response to what the critics have (to say must be very tempting. But I had never considered having to avoid your own genre for fear of absorbing some of their ideas. It makes it easier to swallow Dan Brown’s story) I suppose it makes sense, but it seems like a shame that you can’t read other contemporary writers very often, and I would think that you would like crime fiction best since you write it!

    Well, at least Tony Hillerman is dead now, so you can read his books. I LOVE him :)

Leave a Reply